Le vacarme des Écritures. Penser, croire et philosopher dans l’Inde prémoderne - I. Ratié (2025)

The lecture is a masterful exposition of the historical and philosophical issues surrounding the recognition of Indian philosophy. Ratié demonstrates deep expertise, weaving together historical context, philosophical analysis, and philological insights. She effectively deconstructs the Eurocentric bias that has marginalized Indian thought, citing specific examples such as Husserl’s lecture and Hegel’s views. The argument is well-supported by references to key figures and texts, and she critically engages with the legacy of colonialism in shaping perceptions of Indian philosophy. The lecture is rigorous in its scholarship, yet accessible to a broad audience, making a compelling case for the philosophical significance of India’s intellectual traditions. The only minor limitation is that the lecture is an introduction, and some complex ideas are presented succinctly, but this is appropriate for an inaugural lecture. Overall, it is an excellent contribution to the field and a call to action for further research.

The title accurately reflects the content, which explores the philosophical traditions of premodern India and challenges the Eurocentric view of philosophy.

9/10

The lecture is delivered by a renowned scholar, Isabelle Ratié, professor at the Collège de France, with a strong academic background in Sanskrit and Indian philosophy. The content is well-structured, references historical and philosophical sources, and is presented in an academic setting. The lecture is part of the Collège de France's official channel, ensuring institutional credibility.

Markers derived by PSI from the transcript: the creator did not define chapters.

• 02:00Introduction by the administrator, highlighting Ratié's career and the significance of the chair.
• 05:00Ratié begins her lecture with a quote from Husserl's 1935 conference, setting the stage for her critique of Eurocentrism.
• 10:00Discussion of the early European fascination with Indian wisdom and the creation of the first Sanskrit chair at the Collège de France.
• 15:00Analysis of the shift in European attitudes, influenced by Hegel and the discovery of Buddhism, leading to the denial of Indian philosophy.
• 20:00Ratié argues for the importance of philological work on Sanskrit manuscripts to uncover the philosophical depth of Indian texts.
• 25:00Discussion of the need to distinguish philosophy from religion in the Indian context, while acknowledging their interconnections.
• 30:00Ratié outlines the challenges and opportunities for future research in Indian philosophy, emphasizing the diversity of systems.
• 35:00Conclusion: Ratié calls for a renewed appreciation of Indian philosophy and its relevance for contemporary thought.

• Entretien avec Isabelle Ratié — Interview discussing the denial of Indian philosophy.
• Cours et séminaires d'Isabelle Ratié — Link to Ratié's courses on consciousness and identity in Indian philosophy.
• Collège de France — Institutional website of the Collège de France.

• Entretien avec Isabelle Ratié — Interview where Ratié discusses the denial of Indian philosophy, aligning with the lecture's themes.

• www.fondation-cdf.fr
• fr.linkedin.com
• www.threads.net