Grande Conférence: “The War on Ukraine: What Needs to Change?”

Value of the Information & Strength of the Argument

The value of the information is high, as the speakers provide firsthand insights and expert analysis on the conflict. The argumentation is solid, grounded in their professional experiences and current geopolitical realities. They present coherent arguments for why Russia’s war is not just about territory but about destroying Ukrainian statehood and democracy, and they advocate for a comprehensive strategy combining military support, economic pressure, and long-term reconstruction. The discussion is well-structured and addresses multiple dimensions of the crisis, though it is primarily opinion-based rather than data-driven.

Scientific Rigor, Source Quality, Title Accuracy

The scientific rigor is moderate, as the discussion is based on expert opinion and personal experience rather than cited research. The sources are the speakers themselves, who are credible authorities. The title accurately reflects the content, and the discussion stays on topic. No external sources are cited, but the institutional context of Sciences Po adds credibility. The adequacy between title and content is strong, as the panel directly addresses the question of what needs to change.

The title accurately reflects the content: a high-level discussion on the war in Ukraine and what needs to change.

8/10

Panel of high-level experts and officials, including former ministers, Nobel laureate, and EU Commissioner, providing authoritative perspectives. The discussion is moderated by a journalist, and the content is largely opinion and analysis based on their expertise, with no formal citations. The reliability is high due to the speakers' credentials and the institutional setting.

Markers derived by PSI from the transcript: the creator did not define chapters.

• 00:00Introduction by Sciences Po president, setting the stage for the discussion.
• 05:00Moderator Laure Mandeville introduces the panel and the historical context.
• 10:00Oleksandra Matviichuk recalls the start of the invasion and the resilience of ordinary Ukrainians.
• 15:00Dmytro Kuleba shares his perspective on the invasion and the need to win the right to be helped.
• 20:00Valdis Dombrovskis discusses the EU's immediate response and sanctions.
• 25:00Odile Renaud-Basso talks about the EBRD's decision to suspend disbursements to Russia and support Ukraine.
• 30:00Discussion on Russia's imperial ambitions and the need to increase pressure.
• 40:00Oleksandra Matviichuk explains the economic incentives for Russian soldiers and the concept of 'necronomy'.
• 50:00Dmytro Kuleba outlines the two ways to force Putin to change objectives: stabilize the front and strip oil revenues.
• 1:00:00Panel discusses the role of Europe and the need for a strategic shift.

• Sciences Po App - App Store — Link in description for the Sciences Po app.
• Sciences Po LinkedIn — Link in description to Sciences Po's LinkedIn page.
• Sciences Po Snapchat — Link in description to Sciences Po's Snapchat.

• EU sanctions against Russia — The panel discusses the importance of sanctions, and this official EU source provides details on the sanctions regime.
• Center for Civil Liberties — Oleksandra Matviichuk is the head of this organization, which is relevant to her statements on human rights and accountability.