L'expérience de la Grande guerre | ENS-PSL

The lecture offers a rich and nuanced analysis of Marc Bloch’s wartime experience, drawing on a variety of primary sources and employing a comparative methodology that reflects Bloch’s own historiographical principles. Offenstadt’s expertise is evident in his detailed knowledge of Bloch’s writings and the testimonies of fellow soldiers, which he uses to reconstruct Bloch’s experiences and to highlight the specificity of his perspective. The argument is well-structured, moving from a descriptive account of Bloch’s war to an analysis of his intellectual development and the integration of war into his epistemology. The speaker engages critically with the concept of ’experience’, defending its utility against postmodern critiques, which adds depth to the discussion. However, the lecture is primarily an oral presentation and lacks formal citations, which limits the verifiability of some claims. The reliance on analogies and comparisons, while methodologically sound, occasionally risks overgeneralization. The title accurately reflects the content, and the talk is accessible to an academic audience. Overall, the lecture is a valuable contribution to the historiography of Marc Bloch and the history of WWI, offering fresh insights into the relationship between personal experience and historical scholarship.

The title accurately reflects the content: the talk focuses on Marc Bloch's experience of WWI and its impact on his work as a historian.

8/10

The speaker is a recognized historian (Nicolas Offenstadt) and the talk is hosted by ENS-PSL, a prestigious institution. The content is based on primary sources (Marc Bloch's writings, testimonies of fellow soldiers) and historiographical analysis. The presentation is well-structured and demonstrates scholarly rigor, though it is an oral presentation without formal citations in the video.

Markers derived by PSI from the transcript: the creator did not define chapters.

• 00:00Introduction by the moderator and start of Nicolas Offenstadt's lecture on Marc Bloch and the Great War.
• 02:00Offenstadt introduces his comparative approach, referencing Bloch's own methodological suggestions.
• 05:00Discussion of Bloch's war experience: mobile warfare, marches, and the discovery of violence.
• 10:00Description of trench warfare in the Argonne, including the constant threat of mines and close proximity to enemy lines.
• 15:00Comparison of Bloch's accounts with those of fellow soldiers like Ovide d'Aras and André Delâtre.
• 20:00Analysis of Bloch's intellectual activity at the front and his role as an observer.
• 25:00Discussion of Bloch's participation in major battles, including the Somme and the Chemin des Dames.
• 30:00Exploration of how the war influenced Bloch's epistemology, including his concept of false news.
• 35:00Conclusion: Bloch's war experience as a 'field of experience' and its lasting impact on his work.

• Savoirs ENS — Platform hosting the video and other academic content from ENS-PSL.
• ENS-PSL Official Website — Institutional website of the École normale supérieure - PSL.
• ENS-PSL LinkedIn — LinkedIn page of the school.
• ENS-PSL YouTube Channel — Official YouTube channel of ENS-PSL.

• Marc Bloch: A Life in History — Biographical work on Marc Bloch that corroborates his war experience.
• The Great War and Modern Memory — Paul Fussell's study on the cultural impact of WWI, aligning with the theme of experience.

• Postmodernist critiques of experience — Some scholars, like Foucault and Joan Scott, argue that 'experience' is a construct and not a reliable historical category, which contrasts with Offenstadt's defense of the concept.