The Origins of Atheism - Alec Ryrie

Alec Ryrie’s lecture offers a sophisticated and historically grounded analysis of the origins of atheism, challenging simplistic narratives that attribute the rise of unbelief solely to the Enlightenment. His argument that unbelief has deep medieval roots and was significantly shaped by the Reformation is compelling and well-supported by historical evidence. Ryrie’s use of specific examples, such as Frederick II and the ‘Three Impostors’ legend, illustrates the complexity of medieval unbelief, which often blended resentment of clerical authority with genuine skepticism. The lecture’s strength lies in its nuanced treatment of the relationship between belief and unbelief, emphasizing that both are often driven by emotional and intuitive factors rather than purely intellectual ones. Ryrie’s distinction between ‘practical’ and ‘constructive’ atheism is particularly insightful, as it broadens the definition of unbelief beyond explicit denial of God. The lecture is well-structured, with clear sections that guide the listener through the historical narrative. However, while Ryrie is a recognized expert, the lecture format limits the depth of source citation, and some claims would benefit from more explicit references. The title accurately reflects the content, and the lecture provides a valuable contribution to the history of religion and secularization. Overall, this is a high-quality, thought-provoking lecture that offers a fresh perspective on a topic often oversimplified.

The title accurately reflects the content, which explores the historical origins and development of atheism in Western Europe.

8/10

Lecture by a recognized historian (Professor of the History of Christianity at Durham University, Fellow of the British Academy), based on scholarly research and published sources. The content is well-structured and nuanced, but the lecture format and the lack of explicit citations in the video itself limit the ability to verify every claim directly.

• 00:00// Introduction
• 01:51// How to Be an Atheist in Medieval Europe
• 09:38// How the Reformation Trained Us to Be Sceptics
• 19:54// How to Be a Shakespearean Atheist
• 29:55// How to Be a Puritan Atheist
• 40:01// The Spiritual Quest Against Religion
• 49:47// Jesus, Hitler and the Abolition of God
• 59:35// Outro

• Gresham College - Origins of Atheism series — Official series page with transcripts and additional resources.
• Gresham College YouTube Playlist — Full lecture series playlist.
• Gresham College Website — General information about the institution and its lectures.
• Gresham College on Bluesky — Social media profile for updates and engagement.

• Gresham College - Origins of Atheism series — Official series page with transcripts and additional resources.